Ritz, Andrew has proposed to give credit to your paper and for you to take down your postings on the Internet. What do you think? Actions speak louder than words.
I have not threatened to sue Private Eye, Andrew Bousfield or Phil Hammond. I have requested an apology and a citation to the title of the paper in the next issue of Private Eye. Hammond has already issued one apology for the prior mishap. I have asked for a amendment to the EDM based on the recommendations I drafted in the paper . The documentary evidence in parliament as well as emails to Phil Hammond show that the ideas and recommendations were drafted by me.
Andrew Bousfield is currently threatening to sue me. No doubt his reasons are because the findings of the Bar Standards Board and the Court judgment have now been made public. He wishes to silence those findings. As a officer of the court, Andrew's record in protecting free speech is now of interest to the public.
I stand by all my allegations which are evidence based. I intend to stand by all I have said. I fear nothing.
I would like to thank the The Bureau of Investigative Journalism for their fairness in this matter. Even though Bousfield is a colleague of theirs, they have allowed the debate to continue on their website.
1. In response to the "Officer of the Court" and Free Speech comment. Andrew now insists I am free to write whatever I want.
2. He recently whined at the long suffering Bureau of Investigative Journalism who were forced to add the addition at the bottom after insisting their comments were now closed :)
“Following publication of the Private Eye piece Rita Pal bombarded many of the doctors featured with emails. Five doctors asked her to stop contacting them, one because it created distress. I also did the same. She has since contacted MP’s, my family and my former employers. I wish to have nothing to do with her, and do not propose to continue this debate with her here.” .
Lawyers do twist the facts :). Yet, Bousfield has emailed me consistently despite my one liner requesting he ceases to contact me. He clearly feels the need to spend the next 10 years fighting in court against me instead of issuing an apology and a citation to the paper's recommendations. I suspect Private Eye are now intending on suppressing free speech after their campaign to protect it :). I have asked Hammond whether Bousfield is representing Private Eye and him. There has been no response. According to Andy, I am not allowed to complain, not allowed to mail MPs, not allowed to issue my view of our dealings to other whistleblowers and essentially I am supposed to sit tight and accept that my recommendations were lifted. Fascinating.
It is quite laughable that anyone would feel distressed by me sending our citation to the whistleblowing paper -unless of course this email was issued purposely :) :). There are no rules about contacting Parliament or issuing complaints or sending copies to his father who presents his email address online.
Anyway, if Bousfield wants to fight in court, around court, wishes to stalk me, set the large teethed dogs onto me, the fact remains that the truth of the matter cannot be removed. I developed the recommendations on the Whistleblowing paper and Private Eye lifted them. The correct way to deal with his matter is to write the apology and issue a citation in the next issue of Private Eye. Instead, moves are being made to silence me :). How interesting.
Once the apology and correction is issued, we can progress from the art of minimalist scrapping. Bousfield is a master of minimalist scrapping. I often wonder how I fell into his playground. It is so uninspiring in many ways. I don't even feel like litigating because the other side is so tiresome. Bousfield though is keen keen keen. He wants to litigate litigate litigate. *sigh*. Why don't I have the luck of falling into Ben Emmerson's playground? At least then, I could be dazzled by a barrister's good looks and be thrilled by the idea of litigation.
Until the next update folks...............
Update 21st July 2011.
Gone out to a party - back on Monday.......................
The development of Whistleblowing and Patient Safety has been taking place for over 2 years now. During the development, I sent a draft copy to Private Eye for them to feature. Private Eye did not feature it, instead Phil Hammond and Bousfield decided to lift the recommendations drafted by me and make it theirs.
"Our recommendations are firstly that the profession, through the GMC or BMA Council, should commission a Consultation Group on Reporting Poor Care. This Group will examine the consequences to all parties from incidents of reported poor care. Second, the Government should consider establishing a Health Select Committee Review of Whistleblowing that would make impartial recommendations to Government and the profession. Third, the Government should consider setting up and resourcing a National Whistleblowing Centre similar to that in the US. We believe that only by open public scrutiny will constructive change be cemented into exemplary clinical practice"
These recommendations were lifted by Bousfield and Hammond and inserted into Private Eye without citation. The recommendations have now become part of an EDM in Parliament. The facts are that the above paper was submitted a long ago and that the ideas were infact mine. After the disagreement, I revoked all rights to my ideas offered by email - one being on the National Whistleblowing Centre. Of course, the facts and communications speaks for itself. The solutions were not that of Bousfield or Private Eye. They were developed by me and accepted by the other authors.
Private Eye, Andrew Bousfield and Dr Phil Hammond have purposely stolen the material and refused to place a citation of the above paper by these ideas. Private Eye can do the correct thing and acknowledge the paper with an apology or we can take this matter forward in time. It is clear that none of them have any originality and stoop low enough to steal ideas from research papers without citing them.
I would like to thank Kamran Abassi of JRSM for having the vision and courage to publish this paper. As many journalists and members of the public have requested a copy, it can be downloaded here. Kamran has indeed been a star from start to finish. I pitched this idea to him years ago and finally got the authors together to write it. This is the reference and the original link if download is impossible. If anyone wants a direct copy mailed, please email me.
The reference:-
Stephen Bolsin, Rita Pal, Peter Wilmshurst, and Milton PenaJ R Soc Med 104(7): 278—282; doi:10.1258/jrsm.2011.110034
I must say that working on this paper was extremely difficult. We were under so much pressure to write a pro-establishment paper but we refused and stuck to our principles. Anyhow, I think we did a great job. I of course drafted a lot of the GMC section :). Don't we all love the GMC?! :). I certainly believe the BMA is part of the problem and one that our trade union refuses to address. I for one was never going to do what Professor Jarman wanted us to do - that was write a pro-BMA article.
I have sent this paper to the GMC and requested a consultation on whistleblowing. We shall see what the Gods in the Regulatory sky have to say.
The paper has been well received by many people. I am pleased about that. The Independent ran the piece cleverly missing out the fact I was second author. I love these episodes by them. The person who grafts the hardest is summarily omitted. Anyway, these things amuse me no end as it shows that Nina still holds a grudge against me after I won a copyright argument against her. Jeremy Laurence on the other hand does a fantastic job of describing the issues and I agree with his last para. See his recent article here.
My MP's idea on an Inquiry finally came to fruition - see Nina's excellent piece in the Independent. Here is the evidence from Private Eye itself ""More Staffing Problems Private Eye No 1234 17th - 30th April 2009 "Dr Pal haslobbied (via her MB Andrew Mitchell) for the Commons health select committee to investigate the problems faced by whistleblowers in the NHS" . Subsequently, this request was made to all corners of the NHS, Department of Health and Parliament and more recently though NHS Reform. It is amusing watching everyone run with the idea without acknowledging who actually came up with it in the first place.
What is interesting about this paper is this - despite being written by whistleblowers, the uptake by the medical media has been poor. Why is this? Obviously because the establishment refuses to address the fact that it has problems - serious problems. While many will seek comfort in the safety offered by Dr Gooderham's cosmetic BMJ homage to whistleblowing - with due respect the Blue Dragon had no experience of whistleblowing at all. Sometimes you have to walk on the yellow brick road to write accurately about it. The fact that he analysed PIDA wrongly is largely ignored by many. The research on PIDA is quite the opposite as we point out. The reluctance of the British Medical media and perhaps many of the bloggers to review the paper or even point to it is indicative of our observations - the profession is not ready for reality. Anyhow, for all those who believe that the paper will remain locked away somewhere in the archives of the JRSM, you can be assured that it has now circulated world-wide. The code of silence by the profession is indeed operational as we all predicted. Unlike Gooderham, I am certainly not going to present misleading material and tell the world that the BMA is not part of the problem. It has always been lazy, ineffective and abusive to most junior doctors. Merely because it creeps up to Kim Holt does not mean the rest of us are persuaded.
While I must say the GMC takes baby steps in trying to improve, the BMA has simply placed its head in the sand and it refuses to remove it. I am of course surprised that Fiona Godlee, Jane Smith and Tony D have not congratulated us on publication. Of course, as they well know, the next publication will be about them and their efforts to curb free speech of whistleblowers.
This website is about the General Medical Council's actions against a NHS whistleblower. They conducted a series of revolving door complaints against me between the years 2000-2009.
I am an evidence based NHS whistleblower who raised justified concerns on Ward 87 North Staffordshire NHS Trust in 1999. Many years later, the Care Quality Commission documents showed that the Trust had a increased mortality rate and higher litigation costs than Mid Staffordshire NHS Trust.
Instead of conducting an investigation into the deaths on Ward 87, in the year 2000, the GMC conducted a unlawful "discreet inquiry" into my fitness to practise. On discovery of this in the year 2004, I sued the General Medical Council successfully. During the litigation, the GMC instigated a complaint on defamation. They later admitted their procedures do not deal with defamation despite subjecting me to a six month investigation before clearing me.
The General Medical Council subsequently instigated a spurious complaint on a "link" on the internet and my use of the term "psychiatrist".Having subjected me to a six month investigation whilerecklessly spreading dishonesties to the Trust I was working for, the GMC cleared me. The Trust in question fired me on the GMC's word and the General Medical Council subsequently went on to term it a "resignation" in court. To date, the General Medical Council have not been able to establish a resignation of any kind. Effective as of 2007, my references were stigmatised with a termination of employment and all my future application forms required a declaration of the GMC's spurious investigation. This prejudice to future employment is well understood by all doctors.
To prevent vexatious complaints against doctors, I challenged the General Medical Council in court in 2009. Unfortunately, due to judicial errors, the case did not have the result we expected. Permission to hear the case was won. Sadly, the actual case did not succeed at final hearing. It was heard by Justice Collins who was effectively persuaded by the GMC's blatant dishonesties.
The case though continues following the conflict between R v GMC Ex Parte Pal and R v GMC Ex Parte Remedy UK. The assessment to ensure there is a balance between doctors' and the complainants interests is yet to be analysed by higher courts. The story has not ended.
In the meantime, I have sought to write my thoughts on being a whistleblower, the character assassinations conducted by the GMC and its associates. The GMC networks fairly well and their vested interests have always been clear to all in the medical profession. In 2011, the General Medical Council issued an apology for their behaviour against me.
This is the reality of whistleblowing in the National Health Service. In addition, the domino effect of the entrenched defamation caused by the GMC is often never ending. This website is designed to raise these important issues because there is no media support for whistleblowers who face this kind of establishment assassination. We have attempted to detail this in our paper that can be downloaded through this petition - Whistleblowing and Patient Safety.
I hope that this website goes some way to show how difficult life is for a NHS Whistleblower. I raised concerns in 1998, the repercussions are still ongoing in 2012. In 2004, Judge Harris compared the GMC to a totalitarian regime. Its failures in public safety and its inability to regulate doctors fairly is detailed very well by the media.